The Remarkable Legacy of Muhammad Bin Qasim: A Historical Debate of Reverence and Reality

Introduction

The legacy of Muhammad Bin Qasim holds a unique place in the history of Indo-Arab relations. These relations date back to pre-Islamic times when trade and cultural exchanges flourished between the Indian subcontinent and the Arab world. With the advent of Islam, the spread of its teachings reached India as early as the time of the Sahabah (companions of the Prophet Muhammadﷺ , However, the establishment of Islamic rule in India formally began with the arrival of Muhammad Bin Qasim in Sindh. This monumental event laid the foundation for Islam’s growth in the region and continues to be a subject of historical and academic discourse.

The Advent of Islam in India

Indo-Arab interactions began long before Islam’s emergence, but the religion’s spread to India is believed to have started during the time of the Sahabah. Even before Muhammad Bin Qasim’s arrival, Islamic teachings had reached parts of the Indian subcontinent through trade and missionary efforts. However, it was Muhammad Bin Qasim’s conquest of Sindh that marked a turning point. This event not only brought Islamic governance to India but also set the stage for future Muslim rulers in the region.

Muhammad Bin Qasim’s Historic Conquest

The conquest of Sindh by Muhammad Bin Qasim is often described with a mix of reverence and historical analysis. As the great Muslim leader led his forces into Sindh, he established a precedent of religious tolerance and administrative reforms. The famous quote by Pakistan’s founding father, Muhammad Ali Jinnah, that “Pakistan was born the day Muhammad Bin Qasim stepped into Sindh,” underscores the significance of this event in the broader narrative of South Asian history.

Mohammad Bin Qasim

Divergent Historical Narratives

When studying Muhammad Bin Qasim’s legacy, historians present two primary perspectives. Religious scholars and the devout often highlight his role with a tone of admiration, focusing on his contributions to spreading Islam. On the other hand, some modern historians analyze his conquests through a more neutral or even critical lens. They emphasize the need to distinguish between reverence and historical accuracy. For instance, Professor Muhammad Aslam, in his book “Muhammad Bin Qasim aur Uske Janasheen” (Muhammad Bin Qasim and His Successors), explores the subtleties of these narratives. He asserts that while Muhammad Bin Qasim’s departure from India seemingly paused Islamic history in the region, his legacy persisted through his followers and their continued missionary work.

The Role of Umar Bin Abdul Aziz

 A key aspect of Muhammad Bin Qasim’s legacy is the role played by Caliph Umar Bin Abdul Aziz in promoting Islamic teachings in Sindh. Historical records indicate that after Muhammad Bin Qasim’s departure, many of his soldiers stayed behind, continuing their efforts to propagate Islam. Umar Bin Abdul Aziz’s governance further supported these activities, ensuring that the seeds of Islam sown by Muhammad Bin Qasim flourished over time.

Criticism and Reverence:

Finding Balance: While most Muslim historians regard Muhammad Bin Qasim with profound respect, some critiques focus on ensuring historical accuracy. A recent video presentation on the book by Professor Aslam sparked controversy for its tone. Critics argued that it lacked the respect befitting such a significant historical figure. However, upon closer examination, it becomes evident that the author aimed to maintain objectivity, relying on primary Arabic sources to present an unbiased account. This highlights the ongoing challenge of balancing reverence with factual representation.

Conclusion

The legacy of Muhammad Bin Qasim is a blend of reverence and reality, shaped by both historical facts and cultural sentiments. His conquest of Sindh marked the beginning of a new chapter in Indo-Arab relations, leaving an indelible impact on the region’s history. As scholars continue to explore his contributions, it is crucial to approach his legacy with both respect and a commitment to historical truth. In doing so, we honor not only his memory but also the rich and complex history of Islam in the Indian subcontinent.

If you’re interested in reading this book, click the link below for a free download.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zXNfVXdl5zs5NODnCAOz1rpKsxglPpTj/view?usp=sharing

If you’d like to listen to this book in audio format, click the CONTACT button below to get in touch with the AwazeUrdu team to order the audiobook.

Contact us:

Click the link below to watch the video on Facebook as well.

https://www.facebook.com/share/v/18CWbvKcUX

Click the link below to watch the video on Rumble as

well.https://rumble.com/v5ty50w-arrival-of-muhammad-bin-qasim-in-sindh..html

ہندوستان اورعربستان کےتجارتی تعلقات قبل ازاسلام سے رہےہیں۔ دینِ اسلام کےدنیامیں ظہورکےبعد صحابہؓ کےزمانےمیں ہی اسلام کی دعوت ہندوستان تک پہنچ گئی تھی مگرہندوستان میں اسلامی حکومت کی تاریخ حضرت محمدبن قاسمؒ کےسندھ میں داخلےسےشروع ہوتی ہے۔جیساکہ قائداعظمؒ نےفرمایاتھا کہ پاکستان اسی دن قائم ہوگیاتھا، جس دن محمدبن قاسمؒ نےسندھ میں قدم رکھاتھا۔ مگراسلام کےاس عظیم سپہ سالار سے متعلق تاریخی روایات عموماً دوطرح سےملتی ہیں۔

جیساکہ تاریخی روایات کا اصول ہے کہ ہرمؤرخ عام طور پراپنےذہنی رجحان کےمطابق تاریخ مرتب کرتاہے تویہاں بھی یہی ہوا ہے۔ دیندارطبقے نے انؒ کےبارے میں جوکچھ لکھاہے، اس میں عقیدت کاپہلونمایاں ہے۔ ہونابھی چاہئے کیوں کہ ہندوستان میں اسلام پھیلنےکی بنیاد انہی کے یہاں تشریف لانےسے پڑی۔ مگراس عقیدت میں گُم ہوکر ۔اصلیت سےروگردانی نہیں کرنی چاہئے

پروفیسرمحمداسلم نےاپنی کتاب”محمدبن قاسم اوراس کےجانشین” میں لکھاہے کہ ہندوستان میں اسلام کی تاریخ محمدبن قاسمؒ کے یہاں سے چلےجانےکےبعدخاموش ہوجاتی ہے۔ پھر اس کےتین صدیوں بعد اہلِ غزنہ کی یہاں آمدسے دوبارہ تاریخ کاآغازہوتاہے۔ حالاں کہ  محمدبن قاسمؒ کےیہاں سے چلےجانےکےبعد بھی ان کا اکثر لشکریہاں مقیم رہا۔ بلکہ حضرت عمربن عبدالعزیزؒ کےدور میں دعوتی سرگرمیاں جاری رہیں اورلوگ برابرمسلمان ہوتے رہے۔ اسی تاریخ کو پروفیسراسلم صاحب نےاپنی کتاب میں عربی تاریخی حوالوں کےساتھ بیان کیاہے۔

اس کتاب کا ایک اقتباس،زمرہءتاریخ کی اس ویڈیومیں پڑھاگیاہے، مگراس کے اندازِبیان پرمجھے اعتراض ہے۔ اس لئے اسلام کےاس عظیم سپہ سالار کاتذکرہ ادب واحترام کےساتھ کرناچاہئے۔ مگرحقیقت یہ ہے کہ مصنف نے نہ کوئی گستاخی کیاور نہ ہی غیرضروری عقیدت سے کام لیاہے، بلکہ صرف تاریخی روایات کومدنظر رکھاہے۔ اس ویڈیومیں محمدبن قاسمؒ کےدیبل سے روانہ ہونےکےبعد موجودہ حیدرآباد اور سیہون فتح کرنےکاتذکرہ ہے۔

Leave a Comment